Skip to content
Solutionsโ†’Money
Moneyโœ“ Follow-up at 6 weeks2,560 views

I make a budget every month but I never stick to it

A budget adherence plan using cash envelopes, automated savings, weekly reviews, and realistic category amounts to make budgeting actually stick.

๐Ÿ“Š

Follow-Up Result

6 weeks later

Stayed on budget for 2 consecutive months using the envelope system and weekly check-ins

The Problem

I've made a budget every January for the last five years. By February it's abandoned. I set unrealistic limits, forget about irregular expenses, and when I overspend in one category I give up on the whole thing. I know where my money SHOULD go but I can't seem to make it actually go there. I feel like budgeting works for other people but not for me.

The Plan

Week 1-2: Build a Realistic Budget

  • Track your actual spending for 2 weeks before making a budget โ€” base it on reality, not wishful thinking
  • Include irregular expenses: car registration, holiday gifts, annual subscriptions โ€” divide by 12 and save monthly
  • Build in a "fun money" category โ€” a budget with zero enjoyment is a budget you'll abandon
  • Use the 50/30/20 rule as a starting point: 50% needs, 30% wants, 20% savings/debt
  • Automate savings and bill payments on payday โ€” what's left is what you can spend
  • Week 3-4: Make It Stick

  • Try the cash envelope system for variable categories (groceries, dining out, entertainment) โ€” when the cash is gone, it's gone
  • Do a 10-minute weekly budget check-in every Sunday โ€” catch overspending early instead of discovering it at month's end
  • When you overspend in one category, adjust another โ€” don't abandon the whole budget
  • Use an app that makes tracking easy: YNAB, Mint, or even a simple spreadsheet
  • Celebrate staying on budget โ€” reward yourself (within budget) for hitting your targets
  • Resources

  • YNAB (You Need A Budget) โ€” the best budgeting app, free 34-day trial
  • "The Total Money Makeover" by Dave Ramsey โ€” envelope system and debt-free living
  • r/personalfinance โ€” community budget advice and templates
  • Mint โ€” free budget tracking app
  • Follow-Up Result

    6 weeks in: the cash envelope system was the breakthrough. I withdraw cash for groceries ($400), dining out ($150), and fun ($100) at the beginning of each month. When I can physically see the money running out, I make different choices. The weekly Sunday check-in catches problems early โ€” last month I was overspending on groceries by week 2 and adjusted by meal planning more carefully. I've stayed on budget for 2 full months for the first time ever. The key was making the budget realistic (I was always underestimating groceries) and building in fun money so I didn't feel deprived.
    Ask Neady Your Problem โ†’

    Know someone with this problem?

    Share this solution. They get $5 off their first plan.